Billboard – “Can’t Be Wrong”
“This mid-Atlantic act dispels any hint of a sophomore jinx with this superlative follow-up to its 1999 debut. After a few spins through “Can’t Be Wrong, “ one can’t help but describe this group as a distinct match for Dave Matthews Band. Mottley is a clever, catchy, and ever-inventive songwriter who delivers originals that sparkle like sunlight on gemstones. Mottley’s warm, pleasing voice - and his deft touch on such diverse instruments as acoustic guitar, accordion, and Hammond B-3 is seamlessly merged with a tight, well-balanced three-man band. Mottley and company lend a self-assured, ready-for-prime-time flair to “Can’t Be Wrong.” Gentle balladry (“Nothing on You”) brushes shoulders with literate, acoustic-driven rock (“Hymn for Saturdays”) and tender introspection (“In My Town”). Major label A&R execs take note: These fellows are ready.”
Billboard – “Stormy Words”
“Hooky, modern rock foursome delivers a self-produced indie debut that should reverberate well beyond the act’s mid-Atlantic base. Leader Mottley, who wrote the album’s nine selections, has a strong warm rock-tenor voice and a master craftsman’s touch for melody and words that are unfailingly substantive and intriguing. Acoustic and electric guitars fluid percussion, and bas are perfectly colored with mandolins here, a sax there, and seamless vocal harmonies throughout. The band proudly shows such a multitude of influences (latter-day Doobies sophistication, America-with-guts, Fogelberg/Weisberg jazzy/pop) that it can rightly lay claim to a sound uniquely its own. Though there’s not a weak moment here, “What I Call Life” is one of several cuts that simply beg for AC and top 40 airplay and portend great things to come. “Critic’s Choice”
The Bullet, Mary Washington College
“Clay Mottley is talented and energetic, and is one of the best showcases of talent in the area.”